Pensacola Fishing Forum banner

What is the best bay?

3.5K views 13 replies 10 participants last post by  KnottyBass  
#1 ·
Long time reader first time question asker.

My wife and I live up in Andalusia and have fished Destin bay for a few years.
We used to fish during the week years back before she got a job here at the bank now it's weekends only.

we have a 17ft CC we bring down, but here lately Destin just doesn't seem to produce as many fish as it used to, for us atleast.

would going to pensacola or panama city be a more productive choice?

She likes to catch anything from ladyfish, spanish, reds and trout. Which bay do y'all think typically holds more fish?
 
#2 ·
Good Morning...,
I have never fished Destin, however all the inshore area(s) have taken a beating because of the fuel costs. Fish may still be there, but they have been knocked in the head with sinkers all summer long...
Pensacola bay has fish, and structure, I have no clue about Destin...

Good luck, go for a boat ride, and fishing is a bonus....
 
#3 ·
With the way fuel prices have been it's more like go take a drift in the wind or current 😅

There is more boats inshore now for sure.
When we could fish weekdays we would always fish the edge of the channels north of crap island and we would catch many many large spanish and lady fish with the occasional bullred mixed in.
However since the last 2 years only fishing weekends we have not caught a single redfish doing this. I suppose all the boat traffic has maybe pushed them away from there.
 
#4 ·
Haven't fished the area in a few years but this time of year, we would do a lot of night fishing. Launch your boat at Marler Park and head west into the ICW. Shouldn't need to go more than a couple miles then drift down and hit the lights. Pay attention to your chart plotter or at least launch hour or so before dark. Familiarize yourself with the terrain.
 
#5 ·
Pensacola Bay is one of the deeper inlets on the Gulf Coast. There are a few 50-60+ holes. I feel a lot of people forget that depth is just as much of a factor as surface area when determine where/how to fish a bay. In my opinion, that gives Pensacola Bay a slight edge in terms of fish-ability.
 
#10 ·
It's also hit and miss. Sometimes the bays are really active and then other times the fishing seems quieter. Right now with all the rain the water is stained up and probably lower than average salinity, which for me has historically not made the fishing better. I've never fished Destin or PC bays so I can't compare. Let us know if you gain any insights!