I guess that's more of a personal answer, kind of like what's better Ford or Chevy. If you don't want to spend a lot the Heritage Redfish may be a better buy.
I have the Tarpon 140 and I've got to say that for me it is everything I wanted in a kayak.
The Tarpon has some upgrades that IMO make it a better deal, the Slide-Trax system, the hatches and placement of them, the seat is better (adjustable), etc.
I suggest going somewhere that will let you demo the both of them and see which one gives you the most for the money you want to spend.