I have had all kinds of luck with various top water lures. Top Dog Junior, Super Spook, Popa Dog are the ones I have had the most luck with but when winter roles around I'll move back to Catch Jr, Catch 2000 and Crystal shrimp. Thats a real shame too because theres nothing like them exploding out of the water on your lure or watching them stalk it.
I bought a few of the mirrorlure topwaters but never had much luck. Changed to skitterwalk after I got outfished 4 to 1 in the same spot on identical color mirrorlure by a skitterwalk. Something about the resonance of the rattle