I am looking at these two kayaks and am having trouble deciding which one to get. I have read lots about both and they both seem to be pretty good. I will be using it in the bay, in the gulf to paddle out shark baits and fish within a mile of shore. I am 6'1" and weigh 220. Thoughts?
Don't know much about the Emotion, but the Pescador is a great all around entry level kayak. One thing to point out is 12' is the standard around here, 10' is not going to track very well. Best thing to do is test both.
No question. Pescador. Built from the same mold as older Tarpon 120's, which are a very good fishing kayak design. As Bahen says, the longer boat will track better and save you effort.
Academy has the Ocean Kayak Prowler 13 classic on sale which is an outstanding fishing kayak. I think they want $699 for it. Or, go see Bahen at Pensacola Kayak & Sail...
If you can test them, do so. If not, go with a 12. If you get the 10, you'll like it but you'll be looking to upgrade sooner than later. The 12 should keep you satisfied longer.